Hughes?

Yankees lead 1-0 top of the 8th. The top of the Sox order is coming up. Pettitte is finished. Who do you bring in?

I think most fans right now would bring in Phil Hughes. A few months ago it would have been Brian Bruney. Instead Girardi brought in Phil Coke. The result? A bloop and a blast, and the Red Sox take the lead.

I'm assuming we'll learn soon why Coke was brought in instead of Hughes or Bruney. Girardi will be asked after the game, especially if the Yankees lose. We're highly anticipating his explanation.

Very highly anticipating it.